The US government had come to the conclusion that it did not want an independent spirit on the 38th Floor of the Secretariat and thought that ‘BB-G’ would make a useful scapegoat for the failures of US policy in the Balkans and Somalia. However, it had tried to avoid having to use its veto by going to extraordinary lengths to persuade his supporters to drop him. The State Department barnstormed an OAU summit, sent the Secretary of State himself on a trip to Africa, spread disinformation, and arm-twisted the other members of the Security Council. His official phone lines were tapped – or so he believes. The State Department even tried tempting him to stand down voluntarily with the offer of his own US-financed foundation and a new title – ‘Secretary-General of the United Nations Emeritus’. (Since this would signify ‘honourable discharge’ it was presumably intended to distinguish him from Kurt Waldheim, the predecessor with the somewhat questionable war record.) And yet, when it came to the vote on his future in the Security Council, not even the British supported the Americans – which tells us just what a diplomatic debacle for them this was.
But so what? As Boutros-Ghali says, ‘Only the weak rely on diplomacy [which] is perceived by an imperial power as a waste of time and prestige and a sign of weakness’ (p. 198). Of course, he exaggerates – as the half of his own book that I have summarised above amply demonstrates – but there is a kernel of truth in this observation. And this book, by any standards, is a quite riveting account of how and why the United States tried diplomacy but in the end shrugged its shoulders and cast its veto against Boutros Boutros-Ghali – even though its vital interests were not at stake. It is also likely to make angry anyone who thinks – as I do – that the world diplomatic system can only suffer from the political emasculation of the UN Secretariat. I have added some references to this valuable memoir, with its account of the ‘UN-vanquished’ but its Secretary-General morally ‘Unvanquished’ (the title is a clever pun), on the Updating Pages for my textbook.
Related resources
Strengthening the region’s participation
19 Aug, 2011
Modern Diplomacy – Opening address
14 Aug, 1998
The Diplomacy of Micro States
09 Aug, 2002
Alliances and Small Powers
04 Aug, 1968
A United Nations for the Twenty-First Century
04 Aug, 1996
Consensus Rule Processes
13 Aug, 1998
Regional water cooperation in the Arab – Israeli Conflict: A case study of the West Bank
16 Aug, 2014
The Environmental Movement in the Global South
11 Aug, 2007
Organisational culture of UN agencies: The need for diplomats to manage porous boundary phenomena
05 Aug, 2004
Summitry as intercultural communication
06 Aug, 2009
Unvanquished: A U.S.-U.N. Saga
06 Aug, 1999
Governance fore Health in the 21st Century: A study conducted for the WHO Regional Office for Europe
05 Aug, 2011
The Roads from Rio: Lessons Learned from Twenty Years of Multilateral Environmental Negotiations
10 Aug, 2012
The study of regional integration
15 Aug, 1970
Global Health and the Foreign Policy Agenda
07 Aug, 2008
Democratic Intergovernmental Organizations? Normative Pressures and Decision-Making Rules
07 Aug, 2015
Security for small states
13 Aug, 1999
Peacemaking 1919
09 Aug, 1933
The globalization of public health: the first 100 years of international health diplomacy
17 Aug, 2001
The UN and the world diplomatic system: lessons from the Cyprus and US- North Korea talks
16 Aug, 1996
Tunis Agenda for the Information Society
12 Aug, 2005
The Reform of the United Nations
19 Apr, 2006
Old diplomacy in New York
09 Aug, 1985
Funeral summits
09 Aug, 1996
The IberoAmerican System and its Influence in the Ibero-American Regional Summit Diplomacy
23 Aug, 2008
Diplomacy Before and After Conflict
06 Aug, 2010
Prenegotiation and Mediation: The Anglo-Argentine Diplomacy after the Falklands/Malvinas War (1983-1989)
05 Aug, 2004
The Role of Regional Cooperation in Eradicating Poverty and Aid Dependency in East Africa
23 Aug, 2012
Diplomacy at the UN
03 Sep, 1985
Strengthening Regional Management: A Review of the Architecture for Regional Co-operation in the Pacific
12 Aug, 2005
On Behalf of My Delegation,…: A Survival Guide for Developing Country Climate Negotiators
11 Aug, 2000
Valletta Statement on Multilateral Trade
05 Aug, 2005
International Organisation in World Politics
05 Aug, 2004
Modernising Dutch Diplomacy
09 Aug, 2013
The United Nations: An Introduction
17 Aug, 2012
The New Economic Diplomacy
31 Aug, 2012
The ‘Working’ Non-Aligned Movement: Between Belgrade, Cairo, and Baku – The NAM’s Leadership Visibility
07 Aug, 2020
WHO reform process: documents
16 Aug, 2013
Securing the Future of Multilateral Development Finance: Time for Europe to take the Initiative
21 Aug, 2014
Small States at the United Nations
20 Aug, 2010
The inertia of Diplomacy
07 Aug, 2008
United Nations, Divided World, 2nd ed
09 Aug, 2001
How Much is a Seat on the Security Council Worth? Foreign Aid and Bribery at the United Nations
19 Apr, 2006
The evolution of diplomacy in the Caribbean
02 Aug, 2013
What’s the World Health Organization For?
15 Aug, 2014
Mainstreaming Development in the WTO
19 Aug, 2005
EU Strategy for Africa
14 Aug, 2014
The Oxford Handbook of Modern Diplomacy
23 Aug, 2013
Diplomacy on a south-south dimension
05 Aug, 2004
The Grand Decade for Global Health: 1998-2008
16 Aug, 2013
Our Global Neighbourhood
11 Aug, 1995
ASEAN Education Ministers Meeting (ASED)
04 Aug, 2017
Work Programme on Electronic Commerce
14 Aug, 1998
Development Co-operation Report 2015: Making Partnerships Effective Coalitions for Action
07 Aug, 2015
Global Environmental Politics
03 Aug, 2000
The Clash of Globalizations: Essays on the Political Economy of Trade and Development Policy
15 Aug, 2013
Framework of operational guidelines on United Nations support to South-South and triangular cooperation
09 Aug, 2012
Small States in International Relations
19 Apr, 2006
The Procedure of the UN Security Council
06 Aug, 1998
Power: The nexus of global health diplomacy?
22 Aug, 2014
Regionalism versus Multilateralism
09 Aug, 1996
The Charter of the United Nations: A Commentary
09 Aug, 2002
The European Union and the Latin American and the Caribbean Dialogue: Building a Strong Partnership
14 Aug, 2008
United Nations Handbook 2015-16
07 Aug, 2015
Managing Global Chaos
15 Aug, 1996
The challenge of regionalism
08 Aug, 1958
Culture and Organizations: Software of the Mind
13 Aug, 2010
The Oxford Handbook on the United Nations
08 Aug, 2008
Diplomacy as an instrument of good governance
14 Aug, 1998
Reform of the United Nations Security Council
24 Aug, 2012
Use of language in diplomacy
10 Aug, 2001
The United Nations and Israel
31 Aug, 2012
Innovation in Diplomatic Practice
12 Aug, 1999
Multilateralism and the End of History
06 Aug, 2004
Leadership Selection in the Major Multilaterals
02 Aug, 2001
European Union external action structure: Beyond state and intergovernmental organisations diplomacy
11 Aug, 2018
The development of multilateral diplomacy and its fundamental role in global security and progression.
18 Aug, 2016
The road to dignity by 2030: ending poverty, transforming all lives and protecting the planet
06 Aug, 2014
Internet Governance: A Grand Collaboration
05 Aug, 2004
Global Warming and Global Politics
01 Aug, 1996
Global Health and Foreign Policy
13 Aug, 2015
The Milennium Development Goals Report 2015
01 Aug, 2015
Renewing the United Nations System
19 Aug, 1994
Triangular Co-operation and Aid Effectiveness: Can triangular co-operation make aid more effective?
14 Aug, 2009
Reinventing NATO’s Public Diplomacy
05 Aug, 2005
The MIKTA Way Forward (Briefing Paper #2)
01 Feb, 2015