Decision-Making in the UN Security Council: The case of Haiti, 1990-1997
David Malone is a former Canadian diplomat. During the first five years of the period on which his book focuses he represented Canada at the UN in New York, first on ECOSOC and then as Ambassador and Deputy Permanent Representative with important responsibilities in peacekeeping. Prompted by his country’s close interest in Haiti, this was a valuable vantage point from which to observe the subject of his study: first, how in September 1994 the UN helped restore democratically elected President Aristide to power after he had been removed by a military coup three years earlier; and secondly, how it then tried to assist the re-building of his tattered state. Malone establishes the context with a chapter on the ‘rise and decline of Security Council activism’ from 1990 until 1997 and another on Haiti’s history from 1492 until 1990. Over the five subsequent chapters (including a lengthy conclusion) he tackles his case by means of a lucid and well documented narrative. The conditions that permitted UN military action to change Haiti’s government were ‘singular’: a strong US interest in halting the influx of refugees, no expectation of significant military resistance, and wide regional support. Nevertheless, Malone concludes, the UN had never done anything like this before and a precedent had thus been created. This may, however, be less significant if it is also true, as he suggests, that Washington was permitted a UN cloak for this intervention ‘provided other major powers were given equal latitude in their own back yards’ (Roberts). There is, I fear, nothing new about this sort of thing.
Students of Security Council reform will find useful the short primer on this provided on pages 31 to 33. Those with an interest in multiparty mediation will find this book even more instructive, even though Malone has no interest in the bearing of his case on this particular subject. This aspect is thus best studied via the index references to ‘Caputo, Dante’ (who was OAS as well as UN Special Envoy for Haiti until his resignation in September 1994), ‘Group of Friends’, and ‘Carter mission’, chiefly in chapters 5 and 6. Jimmy Carter’s role is sympathetically treated.
David Malone’s book could have done with more ‘de-thesifying’, as the former Publishing Director of Macmillan’s Academic Division used to call it. Endmatter accounts for forty per cent of it even excluding the index. Chiefly endnotes – many of great interest – much of this might with advantage have been woven into the main text. The chapter summaries are perhaps also too long, there are too many long quotations, and the number of acronyms becomes slightly mind-numbing. The following sentence is not unusual: ‘However, solidarity with GRULAC, which continued to support UNMIH, led to NAM demarches on both Russia and China favouring UNMIH extension.’ Nevertheless, the author cannot be blamed for the titles that groups give themselves. His book remains accessible and of great value. As Adam Roberts says: ‘We need more such studies of how the UN Security Council actually works in crises, and how it interrelates to other institutions and processes.’
Related resources
The Search for Peace
07 Aug, 1997
The Embassy: A story of war and diplomacy
19 Aug, 2016
Track 2 diplomacy and Pakistan
08 Aug, 2003
Embassies under Siege
25 Aug, 1995
Diplomacy Before and After Conflict
06 Aug, 2010
Mediation in International Relations
05 Aug, 1994
United Nations, Divided World, 2nd ed
09 Aug, 2001
FDR’s Ambassadors and the Diplomacy of Crisis: From the rise of Hitler to the end of World War II
24 Aug, 2013
Strengthening of the Coordination of Emergency Humanitarian Assistance of the United Nations
14 Aug, 2009
A kind of diplomatic incantation: Exchanging British and Japanese diplomats in the Second World War
02 Feb, 2012
Cyprus: the search for a solution
05 Aug, 2005
Post Cold War diplomatic training
19 Apr, 2006
The Revenge of Geography: What the Map Tells Us About Coming Conflicts and the Battle Against Fate
16 Aug, 2013
Regional water cooperation in the Arab – Israeli Conflict: A case study of the West Bank
16 Aug, 2014
Managing Global Chaos
15 Aug, 1996
Embassies in Armed Conflict
16 Aug, 2012
The Responsibility to Protect
09 Aug, 2001
Education and Conflict: Complexity and Chaos
08 Aug, 2003
Weapons Overview
13 Aug, 2010