British Diplomacy and the Descent into Chaos: The career of Jack Garnett, 1902-19
Garnett was inclined to be moody, headstrong, quickly bored, and indiscreet in gossiping about his chiefs and their wives. As a result, although able, adventurous, not shy of hard work, deeply patriotic and ambitious, this rather enigmatic man was never promoted beyond first secretary and left the diplomatic service under a cloud when only in his early forties. Perhaps the first general point which John Fisher’s book usefully underlines, therefore, is that either persons like this should not be admitted to the diplomatic profession in the first place or, if they are, should be handled better by those responsible for career development – heads of mission as well as the foreign ministry at home: in particular, they should not be sent to missions where they would have little to do, the fate of Garnett when posted in late 1916 to Tangier, where he idled away days as well as nights playing bridge, and later to Buenos Aires. (This shows that the Foreign Office’s mid-nineteenth century attempt to make a head of mission’s deputy something more than a chargé d’affaires in waiting had not been a complete success.) In the event, on resigning from the diplomatic service three years later, Garnett spent the following decade doing an amazing variety of social work in the East End of London and drifted to the political left; then, on inheriting his substantial family property in Lancashire in 1929, he abandoned the metropolis and became a provincial Tory magnate.
Another point that struck me as particularly interesting was the account of worries over the physical security of the Legation Quarter in Peking, in which Garnett found himself as third (later second) secretary at the British legation in 1905. This was just five years after the siege of this arrogant diplomatic enclave by the Boxers, and the need for precautions against another such assault was still very much in the minds of most diplomats, although Garnett had few concerns about his own safety and was soon fed up with the ‘semi-imprisonment’ of legation life. Among other less known details we learn from John Fisher that in February 1906 the German legation acquired a howitzer and that British ministers were inclined to play down security threats for fear of being withdrawn. (The last point, however, is left a little vague.)
Garnett might have had a relatively short diplomatic career but it was varied, taking him to Constantinople, Bucharest, St. Petersburg, Tehran, Sofia, and Athens, as well as the places already mentioned. (In addition, he served for some time in the Foreign Office’s Parliamentary and Contraband Departments during the First World War.) At most of these postings, in part because he often had little else to do, he found himself involved – socially and otherwise – with their expatriate British communities. In the war these became of more than usual concern to London and afterwards the Foreign Office established a Committee on British Communities Abroad. ‘Diaspora diplomacy’, as my colleague Kishan Rana has called it, has become much more important since, and those interested in its origins would do well to look at John Fisher’s work, including his previously published articles on the subject. The same might be said for those interested in the development of commercial diplomacy, for Garnett was one of its early supporters and this overlapped with attentiveness to the diaspora.
There is much else besides of interest to students of diplomacy as well as diplomatic history in this valuable book. Unlike some I could mention, it also has a good index. I commend it most warmly.
Review by Geoff Berridge
Related resources
Cursed is the Peacemaker: The American Diplomat [Philip Habib] Versus the Israeli General, Beirut 1982
09 Aug, 2002
Brian Barder’s Diplomatic Diary
01 Aug, 2019
Persuasion, trust, and personal credibility
10 Aug, 2012
Internet Guide for Diplomats
10 Aug, 2000
The Consular Dimension of Diplomacy
08 Aug, 1986
The Art of Diplomacy: The American Experience
15 Aug, 1968
Diplomacy: Theory and Practice, 4th ed
13 Aug, 2010
Diplomacy: Theory and Practice, Fifth Edition
13 Aug, 2015
Beyond diplomatic – the unravelling of history
04 Aug, 2002
Statecraft
15 Aug, 2008
Politics Among Nations
11 Aug, 2005
True Brits: Inside the Foreign Office
19 Aug, 1994
Language and Diplomacy: Preface
24 Aug, 2001
Inside Diplomacy
10 Jul, 2000
The Diplomats, 1939-1979
12 Aug, 1994
Essence of Diplomacy
29 Nov, 2005
The Ambassadors and America’s Soviet Policy
08 Aug, 1997
Diplomacy: The world of the honest spy
12 Aug, 1979
Persuasion: bad practices and … others
15 Aug, 2013
21st Century Diplomacy: A practitioner’s guide
16 Jan, 2012
Embassies in Armed Conflict
16 Aug, 2012
Lessons from two fields
05 Aug, 2004
International Regimes
13 Aug, 1983
The Office of Ambassador in the Middle Ages
18 Aug, 1967
Modern Diplomacy: Dialectics and Dimensions
08 Aug, 1980
Diplomatic Education
10 Aug, 2007
A Dictionary of Diplomacy
11 Feb, 2000
The inertia of Diplomacy
07 Aug, 2008
The Evolution of Diplomatic Method
17 Aug, 1977
A Diplomat in Japan
04 Aug, 1921
The British Diplomatic Service 1815-1914
04 Aug, 1983
Ottoman Diplomacy
06 Aug, 2004
DiploDialogue – Metaphors for Diplomats
30 Aug, 2013
The Work of Diplomacy
09 Aug, 2002
The Limits of Neorealism
06 Aug, 2004
Just a Diplomat
17 Dec, 2008
A Dictionary of Diplomacy, Second Edition
14 Aug, 2003
The Summer Capitals of Europe, 1814-1919
03 Aug, 2017
Diplomacy, Satire and the Victorians
01 Aug, 2018
Theatre of Power: The Art of Signaling
06 Aug, 1987
The Palgrave Macmillan Dictionary of Diplomacy
17 Aug, 2018
The Queen’s Ambassador to the Sultan: Memoirs of Sir Henry A. Layard’s Constantinople Embassy, 1877-1880
10 Mar, 2010
Twitter for Diplomats
15 Aug, 2013
Embassies and Foreign Courts
03 Aug, 1856
On the manner of practising the new diplomacy
19 Apr, 2006
Reflections on multistakeholder diplomacy
19 Apr, 2006
The Visa Dimension of Diplomacy
06 Aug, 2004
Satow’s Diplomatic Practice, 6th ed
25 Aug, 2011
Diplomacy for the New Century
13 Aug, 1998
Pragmatics in diplomatic exchanges
10 Aug, 2001
The Rise of Modern Diplomacy, 1450-1919
13 Aug, 1993
Innovation in Diplomatic Practice
12 Aug, 1999
The idea of diplomatic culture and its sources
13 Aug, 2004
Diplomat’s Dictionary
07 Aug, 2010
Manuel de droit diplomatique
11 Aug, 1994
Why Persuasion? Reflections after 50 years of practising, teaching and studying diplomacy
09 Aug, 2013
Diplomacy by other means
16 Aug, 2002
A Selection of New diplomatic memoirs
04 Aug, 2000
Performance Management in Foreign Ministries: Corporate Techniques in the Diplomatic Service
05 Aug, 2004
The Nineteenth Century Foreign Office
06 Aug, 1971
Public diplomacy: Taxonomies and histories
08 Aug, 2008
John le Carré: The Biography
28 Aug, 2015
Diplomacy and Global Governance: The Diplomatic Service in an Age of Worldwide Interdependence
10 Aug, 2012
Lucky George: Memoirs of an Anti-Politician
29 Sep, 2005
Diplomatenleben
23 Aug, 2013
Diplomats as cultural bridge builders
12 Aug, 2004
Persuasion in sociology of diplomacy
02 Aug, 2013
Positive Diplomacy
06 Aug, 1999
The New Diplomacy
02 Aug, 2002
The Professional Diplomat
21 Aug, 1969
The Turkish Embassy Letters
12 Aug, 1994
Diplomacy: Theory and Practice, 2nd edn
08 Aug, 2002
How do you know what you think you know?
02 Aug, 2002
Diplomacy and the American Democracy
12 Aug, 1988
Diplomatic culture and its domestic context
13 Aug, 2004
Diplomatic Theory from Machiavelli to Kissinger
12 Aug, 2001
British Envoys to Germany 1816-1866
09 Nov, 2006
The New Diplomacy
16 Aug, 2002
I’ll be with you in a Minute Mr. Ambassador: The Education of a canadian Diplomat in Washington
09 Aug, 1991
The Practice of Diplomacy, 2nd ed
20 Aug, 2010
Mediation in International Relations
05 Aug, 1994
Multistakeholder diplomacy at the OECD
19 Apr, 2006
Routledge Handbook of Public Diplomacy
14 Aug, 2008
Yes, (Saudi) Minister! A Life in Administration
06 Aug, 1999
Language, signaling and diplomacy
10 Aug, 2001
Embassies under Siege
25 Aug, 1995
Diplomacy for a Crowded World
13 Aug, 1976
Bertie of Thame: Edwardian Ambassador
04 Aug, 1990
The Oxford Handbook of Modern Diplomacy
23 Aug, 2013
Getting Our Way: 500 Years of Adventure and Intrigue: The Inside Story of British Diplomacy
13 Aug, 2011
The impact of the Internet on diplomatic reporting: how diplomacy training needs to be adjusted to keep pace
23 Aug, 2013
Ever the Diplomat
24 Aug, 2013
English Medieval Diplomacy
09 Aug, 1985
21st Century Diplomacy: A Practitioner’s Guide
08 Sep, 2011
Inside Diplomacy
10 Aug, 2000
Diplomacy at the Cutting Edge
12 Aug, 2016
Diplomacy: Theory and Practice, 3rd edn
04 Aug, 2005
The School for Ambassadors
11 Aug, 1922
The Foreign Office
11 Aug, 1955
Bilateral Diplomacy
19 Apr, 2007
Quick Diplomatic Response
10 Aug, 2007
The Diplomats, 1919-1939
11 Aug, 1994
Renaissance Diplomacy and the Reformation
18 Aug, 1989
Diplomacy: Theory and Practice
12 Aug, 2005
FDR’s Ambassadors and the Diplomacy of Crisis: From the rise of Hitler to the end of World War II
24 Aug, 2013
Texts in diplomacy
16 Aug, 2001
Reforming Diplomacy: Clear Choices, New Emphases
26 Aug, 2011
Japanese middle-power diplomacy
10 Aug, 2012
A practitioner’s view
04 Aug, 2001