Transformational Diplomacy after the Cold War: Britain’s Know How Fund in Post-Communist Europe, 1989-2003
We are fortunate that this one has been released to the general public because it is based on official papers which would otherwise have remained classified for many years to come. For information on the contents of the book and its author, together with a preview of the first 30 pages, see here.
The ‘Know How Fund’ is short-hand for a programme of technical assistance conceived in the FCO to bring to fruition British prime minister Margaret Thatcher’s dream of transforming the countries of the former Soviet empire, including Russia itself, into free market economies with liberal-democratic political institutions. It was not, therefore, a conventional bilateral ‘foreign aid’ programme with an emphasis on economic development: instead, its chief thrust was political, the more so because of the geographical proximity of these countries to western Europe and the massive security threat they had long presented. The KHF was also driven by an anxiety not to be outdone by the Germans and the Americans in the struggle for influence in them and for commercial advantage in their new markets. It took shape in programme teams in London, inter-departmental Whitehall committees, and project teams in British embassies (some newly opened) in the region – all assisted more or less ably by an army of non-government advisers, from over-paid bankers and management consultants to police officers and employees of the BBC. It started with a focus on Poland and ended with a concentration on Russia.
Keith Hamilton’s authoritative study provides many insights into the strengths and weaknesses of the KHF and the circumstances in which it prospered and those in which it did not, and it will therefore be of great value to those with an interest in how to conceive and administer this sort of programme. It provided, he concluded, ‘a model for the later deployment of technical assistance in support of specific foreign policy objectives.’ (With the benefit of post-2008 hindsight, it might however be regarded as laughable – if in principle admirable – that so much of the British effort was put into giving advice on best practice in banking and financial services.) The book will also be very useful to students of British relations with the countries concerned over this recent period. Inevitably, it contains a great deal of administrative history (and a plethora of abbreviations). We learn how the programme was set up and about the tensions which developed over its aims between the ‘Diplomatic Wing’ of the FCO and its foreign aid wing, tensions later magnified when Tony Blair came to power in 1997 and made the latter – with its ‘pro-poor agenda’ – into a separate department (DfID). There are also many summaries of the contents of key internal documents. Some will find this sort of thing rather dull but it is all an important part of the record.
‘Transformational’ diplomacy inevitably requires the injection of some funds into a target country even if the emphasis is on technical assistance rather than direct economic assistance or financial relief. This carries a small risk of propping up its creaking conservative regime. A programme conducted in a manner too patronising in tone or clumsy and inefficient in implementation might carry a still greater risk of this sort by stimulating nationalist feelings. To avoid or at least minimise these risks requires first class local knowledge and wide-ranging local contacts – in short, suitably staffed embassies. What is their ideal role? They identify the right projects and monitor their progress; they also provide safe platforms from which experts can operate and have the professional expertise to soothe the reactionaries who might otherwise be disposed to sabotage the desired ‘transformation’. Not surprisingly, by 2002 the British embassy in Moscow had a large KHF section with locally engaged Russians among its staff. When the locally unpopular step has to be taken of running down a programme as a whole and the thoughts of those at home have already turned elsewhere, the embassy might well find actual project management delegated to it as well, as happened to the British embassies in the Baltic republics, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, and Slovakia after 2001. This is the sort of interesting fact with which this important, well balanced, and predictably well written book is crammed. I salute Dr Hamilton for giving it to us.
Related resources
Making Foreign Policy: A Certain Idea of Britain
15 Mar, 2000
Diplomacy and the American Democracy
12 Aug, 1988
Diplomacy and Developing Nations: Post-Cold War foreign policy-making structures and processes
15 Aug, 2009
The British Interests Section in Kampala, 1976-7
16 Aug, 2012
2021: The emergence of digital foreign policy
02 Mar, 2021
European Union external action structure: Beyond state and intergovernmental organisations diplomacy
11 Aug, 2018
The Yugoslav diplomatic service under sanctions
13 Aug, 1998
Health, security and foreign policy
19 Apr, 2006
Britain and Southern Africa
04 Aug, 1983
Diplomatic Interference and the Law
12 Aug, 2016
Modernising Dutch Diplomacy
09 Aug, 2013
The Imperial Component in Iran’s Foreign Policy: Towards Arab Mashreq and Arab Gulf States
19 Aug, 2011
Global Health and the Foreign Policy Agenda
07 Aug, 2008
Experiences of China
05 Aug, 1994
Tested in Times of Transition
24 Aug, 2012
True Brits: Inside the Foreign Office
19 Aug, 1994
South Africa, the Colonial Powers and ‘African Defence’: The rise and fall of the white entente, 1948-60
20 Aug, 1992
Understanding Iran’s Media Diplomacy
24 Aug, 2012
Nixon’s Trip to China
08 Aug, 2003
World on Fire: How Exporting Free-Market Democracy Breeds Ethnic Hatred and Global Instability
08 Aug, 2003
The Embassy: A story of war and diplomacy
19 Aug, 2016
Will WikiLeaks Hobble U.S. Diplomacy?
20 Aug, 2010
Economic Statecraft
15 Aug, 1985
The United Nations and Israel
31 Aug, 2012
Oslo Ministerial Declaration – global health: a pressing foreign policy issue of our time
09 Aug, 2007
Years of Upheaval
20 Aug, 1982
Small States and the Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP) of the EU: A Comparative Analysis
11 Aug, 2000
Impact of Russia’s Foreign Energy Policy on Small European States’ Security. Case Study: The Baltic States
15 Aug, 2009
Current developments in South African diplomacy
14 Aug, 1998
Unvanquished: A U.S.-U.N. Saga
06 Aug, 1999
Diplomacy for a Crowded World
13 Aug, 1976
A Digital DFAT: Joining the 21st Century
06 Aug, 2010
Japanese middle-power diplomacy
10 Aug, 2012
US Public Diplomacy: A Cold War Success Story?
10 Aug, 2007
Secret, lies and diplomats
10 Aug, 2007