The 'essentially contested concept' of security is analysed, and some main kinds of ambiguity and dimensions outlined: level, kind of threat and kind of defence. Discourses on security, particularly of small nations, must avoid being trapped into dealing only with one level (national, which in practice normally means state), one kind of threat (military) and one kind of defence (again military). There is no clear relation between kind of alignment and military expenditures, but non-aligned states are overrepresented both among the very high armers and among the very low armers. Increasing gaps in military R&D make it necessary for small states to rely more on different military strategies from the great powers, putting more stress on invulnerability and on non-offensive defence. For bi- or multi national states, the relation between nations and state becomes crucial for any defence, and in particular for social and cultural defence, which presupposes the absence of major grievances that can be exploited by external powers. In welfare terms, but also in terms of national independence, economic threats are often at least as serious as military ones One remedy is diversification of export commodities and of trade partners. Collective strategies of small states suffer from the 'free rider' problem, and from the vulnerability to collective counter-strategies from centre actors. It is therefore wise of the Non-Aligned Movement not to have attempted to become a military actor. Collective economic strategies will have to take other forms than the producers' cartel, whose difficulties are almost always forbidding.
Related resources
On Behalf of My Delegation,…: A Survival Guide for Developing Country Climate Negotiators
11 Aug, 2000
Climate change, small island developing states
04 Aug, 2005
Roaring Mice Against the Tide: The South Pacific Islands and Agenda-Building on Global Warming
09 Aug, 1996
Persuading and resisting persuasion
15 Aug, 2013
The Diplomacies of New Small States: The case of Slovenia with some comparison(s) from the Baltics
09 Aug, 2001
Persuasion: importance of trust, relevance for small states, and limitations of computers
08 Aug, 2013
Small States in the Global Economy
16 Aug, 2001
Small Economies in the Face of Globalisation
09 Aug, 2002
Alliances and Small Powers
04 Aug, 1968
Small State Diplomacy
15 Aug, 2008
Security for small states
13 Aug, 1999
How important is the role of small states security in the maintenance of international peace and security?
12 Aug, 2016
The changing phases of diplomacy in a Small Island Developing State: A case study of the Kingdom of Tonga
19 Apr, 2006
The miscalculation of small nations
21 Aug, 2008
A Framework of Best Practices for Caribbean Small States to Meet the Challenges of Climate Change
04 Aug, 2010
Small States and the Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP) of the EU: A Comparative Analysis
11 Aug, 2000
Special Ministerial Event on Food Security and Sustainble Development in Small Island Developing States
12 Aug, 2005
21st Century Diplomacy: A Practitioner’s Guide
08 Sep, 2011
The Diplomacy of Small States
17 Aug, 2007
Small States in International Relations
19 Apr, 2006
Meeting the needs of microstate security
15 Aug, 2002
Small Island Developing States and Climate Change: Effects, Responses and Positions beyond Durban (WP)
10 Aug, 2012
An assessment of economic and commercial diplomacy in micro-states: A case study of Namibia
06 Aug, 2014
The Diplomacy of Micro States
09 Aug, 2002
Small States and Alliances
31 Aug, 2001
The Limits of Neorealism
06 Aug, 2004
Small States at the United Nations
20 Aug, 2010