Yellow banner with pen and letters

Author: Paramjit S. Sahai

Mexico and its Diaspora in the United States: Policies of Emigration since 1848

2011

This book is unique in many ways and is different from other studies on migration and diaspora. Délano looks at migration from the perspective of a sending state, focusing on its role in the evolution of emigration policies, as they are shaped under diverse pressure. Spread over a period of over 100 years, the content is neatly divided into five distinct phases. A departure from other studies, the emigration process is seen through the prism of a social scientist and not that of an anthropologist, as is the standard pattern. Its focus is on Mexican emigration policies, yet the same are not seen through Mexican eyes alone, but viewed, too, from an American perspective. Not only is it a theoretical treatise, it is also based on knowledge acquired at a practical level through working experience in the consulates.
761x1200.jpg

Migration policies between asymmetrical states

Does the author succeed in achieving her objectives? To do so, it would be necessary to understand the prepositions that she set for herself or the hypotheses she wanted to prove.  Are migration flows and policies linked to variations in the United States-Mexican relationship and could Mexico, as a weaker actor, control ‘immigration flows’ and address their causes and effects? Délano’s book is a window on migration flows – an examination of Mexico’s emigration policies covering different periods and connecting migration policies with overall policies. She also raises the issue of whether asymmetry in the relationship between a sending state and a receiving state has an impact on migration policies. How does enhancement of economic relations impact emigration policies? Is there a direct or indirect interaction?

Diaspora vis-à-vis communities

Délano correctly sets the ball rolling as she grapples with the definitional problem by noting that people relate to the word ‘Diaspora’ in different ways. She opts to use ‘Diaspora’ in the title as opposed to the more commonly used term, ‘Mexican Communities’, a term that denotes the temporary nature of migration to the United States. ‘The term Diaspora reflects the continuing struggle within the Mexican State to define its position on emigration’, as well as to capture ‘the diversity of Mexican migrants and their organizations’. She notes that the Diaspora has not acted as ‘a unified bloc with common goals, either in relation to their political objectives in Mexico or the United States’. This non-unified approach is equally true of other Diaspora groups across the world, including the Indian Diaspora.

Migration and foreign policy perspective

The book views migration from the foreign policy perspective and how it emerged from the agenda of ‘low politics’ to ‘high politics’.  There is a growing recognition that it impacts other interests of the state and could create ‘conflict situation’ if not fully addressed. The migration issue has to be seen in bilateral, regional, multinational, and transnational contexts. Délano touches on the domestic sensitivity of migration-related issues. She also recognises that security issues act as a damper. Furthermore, increased economic engagement through groupings, such as the North America Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), has created a positive environment for discussion of migration-related issues. Given this importance, should there be coupling or decoupling of migration from other issues? The preference is for decoupling, although experts are divided.

A passive vs active approach on migration

Délano notes that over the years, a passive approach on migration issues has given way to an active involvement on the part of Mexico. While there was more active involvement during the period 2000–2006 in the administration of Mexican President Vincent Fox, the same is not true in the administration of Felipe Calderon since 2006. Mexican migration policy transformed itself from the traditional policy of ‘limited engagement’ and ‘limited response’ to a proactive policy during the 1990s. This happened under pressure from domestic and transnational actors and the growing strength of the Mexican Diaspora in the United States.  The focus is on addressing “the causes of emigration, economic rights in Mexico and protection of their rights in the United States’.  The strength of the Mexican Diaspora has also resulted in changes in their citizenship laws and voting rights.

Engagement, the best option on migration

There are hurdles faced by the sending country (Mexico) in pursuing its agenda on migration.  Délano comes to the conclusion that engagement is a far better option, as otherwise it would have more to lose. While recognising the constraints arising from an asymmetrical relationship, she also recognises that the sending country could get meaningful concessions by using the available channels like lobbying in the United States to put across its view point.

Domestic compulsions still dictate

Migration from Mexico to the USA is a complex phenomenon and there is no parallel in the world.  So much so that ways have to be found to create frameworks, through institutions like the Institute of Mexicans Abroad (IME) and the Consular Identity Card (Matricula), which facilitate in safeguarding the interests of undocumented persons. Nonetheless, domestic compulsions ultimately rule and in the case of the United States, it is becoming more complex with the involvement of the states in the formulation/implementation of emigration policies.  It is such compulsions that have so far derailed President Obama’s Agenda on Migration, which has eluded consensus among the Democrats and the Republicans.

Formalised vs flexible approach

Délano raises a fundamental question, as to whether a formalised relationship on migration would be more in Mexico’s national interest. Given the practical difficulties in reaching a bilateral agreement with the United States, Délano opts for a flexible approach and the need to avoid a straightjacket situation. She concludes that ‘interdependence and the framework in economic integrations have provided Mexico, even though a weaker state, with a wider space for action’ on emigration policies.  This may be true for Mexico, but may not be so for other sending countries. There is, however, a growing realisation among them not to accept things passively, as they make efforts to safeguard the interest of their Diasporas.

A comprehensive treatise

Délano needs to be complimented for a comprehensive treatise on the evolution of Mexican emigration policies and the role of its diaspora in the United States. Her work equally touches on the political clout that the Diaspora has acquired in Mexico and provides a mine of factual data, and useful information and analysis for understanding the relationship ‘not in the limited context of migration, but in the larger context of bilateral relationship, between the two countries’.
Review by Paramjit S. Sahai

You may also be interested in

kaupokalda-com-20160926-dji_0446.jpg

Conclusion of 5th Conference for Honorary Consuls of Estonia

Honorary Consuls of Estonia from 44 countries worldwide gathered for the 5th conference, highlighting the importance of the event for networking, knowledge-sharing, and strengthening ties with Estonia. The conference included visits to various institutions, discussions on consular issues, and a charitable donation. With 104 honorary consuls in 50 countries, their voluntary efforts play a crucial role in fostering connections and assisting Estonian citizens globally, contributing significantly to diverse fields such as politics, economics, and culture.

31pXwtc0KOL.jpg

Consular Law and Practice, 2nd edn

The author of this book is a member of the US State Department's Senior Executive Service, Chairman of the International Law Association Committee on the Legal Status of Refugees, and Adjunct Professor of Law at the American University. It is not a new book but is still available on demand from OUP (when you look at the price, though, who is holding the pistols is a moot point). The first edition was published in 1961, shortly before consular law was codified in the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations (1963), and the method of the second edition is correspondingly different in emphasis - d...

Foreign.png

Consular Services Annual Report 2008/09

The Consular Services Annual Report 2008/09 showcases the work and assistance provided to citizens in need during the specified period.

The Scottish Diaspora and Diaspora Strategy: Insights and Lessons from Ireland

The text discusses the Scottish Diaspora and Diaspora Strategy, drawing insights and lessons from Ireland.

clingendael-2018.png

The transformation of consular affairs: The United States experience

The United States has undergone a significant evolution in consular affairs, largely due to technological advancements and changing global dynamics. This transformation has enabled consular services to become more efficient, accessible, and secure. Modernization efforts include the adoption of biometric data, online appointment systems, and streamlined application processes. As a result, the U.S. consular network is better equipped to serve the needs of citizens, promote national security, and facilitate international travel and trade.

Diplo-publication_Diplomacy-and-Ancient-Greece-G.R.Berridge_FINAL.jpg

The Diplomacy of Ancient Greece – A Short Introduction

Employed against a warlike background, the diplomatic methods of the ancient Greeks are thought by some to have been useless but by others to have been the most advanced seen prior to modern times.

31Wc9HHPtNL._SX313_BO1204203200_.jpg

Consular Law and Practice, 3rd ed

First published in 1961, Consular Law and Practice is a classic work of great interest and practical use to diplomats, consuls, and international lawyers.

761x1200.jpg

Mexico and its Diaspora in the United States: Policies of Emigration since 1848

This book is unique in many ways and is different from other studies on migration and diaspora. Délano looks at migration from the perspective of a sending state, focusing on its role in the evolution of emigration policies, as they are shaped under diverse pressure. Spread over a period of over 100 years, the content is neatly divided into five distinct phases. A departure from other studies, the emigration process is seen through the prism of a social scientist and not that of an anthropologist, as is the standard pattern. Its focus is on Mexican emigration policies, yet the same are not se...

The NIRSA Diaspora Strategy Wheel and Ten Principles of Good Practice

A Diaspora Strategy is an explicit and systematic policy initiative or series of policy initiatives aimed at developing and managing relationships between homelands and diasporic populations. These policy initiatives vary from highly formalised and structured programmes to projects that are quite light in conception and application. A diaspora strategy is perhaps best thought of then as an overarching framework for providing a level of coherence to the range of diaspora policies devised and implemented by a variety of agencies. The NIRSA Diaspora Wheel is designed as a checklist for poli...

cC2pEbgutHi2AHNN7s2V4QetExW.jpg

The Journey of Man: A Genetic Odyssey

If God ever gave mankind a mission – it was not so much to multiply as to walk. And walk we did, to the farthest corners of the earth. Homo sapiens sapiens is the only mammal to have spread from its place of origin, Africa, to every other continent – before settling down to sedentary life ogling a TV screen or monitor, that is.

31AytxwC3PL._SX331_BO1204203200_.jpg

Global Diasporas: An Introduction

The text discusses the concept of diasporas, exploring how people are dispersed across the world while maintaining connections to their homelands. It examines the impact of globalization, technology, and migration on diasporic communities, emphasizing the complexity and diversity of diasporic experiences. Additionally, it highlights the significance of identity, belonging, and transnational connections within diasporas, shedding light on the dynamic nature of diasporic cultures.

315jsxs7PL._SX331_BO1204203200_.jpg

The Craft of Diplomacy: How to Run a Diplomatic Service

The text discusses the key aspects of diplomacy and how to effectively manage a diplomatic service.

Migration-and-Remittances-Factbook-2016.png

Migration and Remittances Factbook 2016

The Migration and Remittances Factbook 2016 provides comprehensive data on global migration patterns and trends, as well as the impact of remittances on economies worldwide. It covers topics such as migration flows, remittance trends, and policy issues related to migration. The factbook serves as a valuable resource for policymakers, researchers, and anyone interested in understanding the dynamics of migration and remittances on a global scale.

1528366822236.png

United States Diplomatic and Consular Staff in Tehran (United States of America v. Iran)

The United States took Iran to the International Court of Justice over the 1979 hostage crisis. The US argued Iran violated international law by holding American embassy staff captive. Iran countered with claims of US intervention in Iranian affairs. The Court ruled in favor of the US, directing Iran to release the hostages and provide reparations. Ultimately, the situation strained US-Iran relations and remains a key diplomatic precedent.

clingendael-2018.png

Think global, act local: Honorary consuls in a transforming diplomatic world

The paper explores the role of honorary consuls in trade, tourism, and investment promotion. It emphasizes the importance of extending consular coverage through honorary consuls, focusing on the significance of localities over national capitals in business and commerce. Selected nations are utilizing honorary consuls to boost their economies. The conclusion highlights research gaps regarding the effectiveness of honorary consuls in trade and investment promotion.

51isJJac2lL._SX328_BO1204203200_.jpg

Diaspora Diplomacy: Philippine Migration and its Soft Power Influences

Diaspora Diplomacy: Philippine Migration and its Soft Power Influences is about the remarkable and untapped soft power that international migrants possess and how various sectors-from governments, NGOs, business, and international organizations- could tap this valuable resource to enhance global cooperation and development. With compelling stories from Filipina and Filipino migrants in San Francisco, London, Dubai, Dhaka, and Singapore comprising the large Philippine diaspora, this book illustrates how this widespread community performs numerous acts of public diplomacy, bridging the cultural ...

umcrest.png

Paradiplomatic’ Relations between the United States and Kosova: A Friendship between an Elephant and a Mouse

Naim Dedushaj's thesis 'Paradiplomatic relations between the United States and Kosova' studies the relations between the Albanian nation and America that date way back in history. The first Albanian immigrants moved to the United States in the second half of the 19th century. The major migration flows from Kosova and other parts in ex-Yugoslavia took place in the 20th century.

umcrest.png

Diaspora Diplomacy: A Case Study of Uganda

International migration in the 21st Century is attracting a lot of attention of policy makers due to its global impact and increasing linkages to development in an era of increased cooperation and interdependence between countries.

The Visa Dimension of Diplomacy

The text provides an overview of how visas play a crucial role in diplomatic relations between countries. It discusses the importance of visa policies in shaping international interactions, fostering bilateral relationships, and promoting various diplomatic objectives. The article emphasizes the significance of understanding the visa dimension in diplomacy for effective communication and cooperation between nations. Overall Summary: The text explores the essential role visas play in diplomatic relations, highlighting their significance in shaping international interactions and fostering bilate...

umcrest.png

Consular Diplomacy: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis and Decision Making

This dissertation explores the consular functions performed in three developed countries and draws from that data to develop a conceptual framework for decision making and analysis of consular affairs. The paper examines the historical evolution of consular functions and the problems of defining consular functions on a universal basis. The findings of this research initially define the categories of consular services performed in contemporary diplomacy, and subsequently, conceptualises how each function may become relatively more important to a nation state. Among the important finding of this...

British-Diplomacy-in-Turkey-1583-to-the-Present.jpg

British Diplomacy in Turkey, 1583 to the Present: A Study in the Evolution of the Resident Embassy

The text discusses the evolution of the resident embassy in Turkey from 1583 to the present, focusing on British diplomacy in the region. It delves into the historical development and changes in diplomatic practices over time.

The inertia of Diplomacy

Diplomacy is used to manage the goals of foreign policy focusing on communication. New trends affect the institution of diplomacy in different ways. Diplomacy has received an additional tool in the form of the Internet. In various cases of interdependence and dependence interference in a country’s affairs is accepted. Multilateral cooperation has created parliamentary diplomacy and a new type of diplomat, the international civil servant. States and their diplomats are in demand to curb the excesses of globalization. The fight against terrorism also brought additional work for diplomac...

Rana-min-1.jpg

India’s diaspora diplomacy

India emphasizes the importance of its diaspora in expanding its global influence through diaspora diplomacy, focusing on enhancing connections with people of Indian origin worldwide.

41DVT7pC0YL._SX326_BO1204203200_.jpg

The Consular Dimension of Diplomacy

The Consular Dimension of Diplomacy discusses the crucial role consular officials play in protecting the interests of their respective countries and citizens abroad. Consular work includes providing assistance to citizens in distress, issuing visas, promoting trade and cultural exchanges, and handling legal matters. This aspect of diplomacy is often overlooked but is vital in maintaining relationships and safeguarding the welfare of citizens outside their home countries.