Yellow banner with pen and letters

Author: Aldo Matteucci

The Long Summer: How Climate Changed Civilisation

2004

Nothing is more changeable than ancient history. As we begin to interpret nature’s archives new insights emerge, overthrowing older orthodoxies, only to be toppled in turn by the next spate of facts. Brian Fagan's latest book too is but history in progress, with a fairly short shelf-life. In some parts it has already been challenged [1].
fagan.jpg

The books greatest merit – to have tried to place climate and ancient history side-by-side – remains unchallenged. And so is its main lesson. Climate will change. Human ingenuity will offset the change at first by ‘deepening’ agricultural technologies – scaling them up – and adjusting social structures to suit the changed situation. ‘In our efforts to cushion ourselves against smaller, more frequent climate stresses, we have consistently made ourselves more vulnerable to rarer but larger catastrophes. The whole course of civilisation may be seen as a process of trading up on the scale of vulnerability.’

I have written the term ‘consistently’ in italics – for a reason. As Jared Diamond shows in his latest book [2], this is not a deterministic process or even a consistent pattern. Some societies managed to adapt to climatic change; other have chosen to fail. The Vikings in Greenland chose to starve to death rather than eat readily available fish. Other societies, on the other hand, just did not have the technologies to adapt – and perished.

For the last 500,000 of the past 780,000 years the world’s climate has been oscillating from warm to cold and back again. Glacial periods have lasted much longer than the warmer periods. Starting with the Holocene (10,000 years ago) an unprecedented long summer began. Our civilisation arose during a remarkably long summer. Mankind, however, was already on the move long before that time.

In Europe the ice cap – 4 km thick – reached the shores of the continent. It was surrounded by rubble-strewn desert, and encircled by steppe/tundra further to the south. Cro-Magnons lived from hunting reindeer and waterfowl, fishing salmon, and they protected themselves from the cold with layered clothing sown with needle and thread. ‘We can imagine late Ice Age Europe as a breathing continent, drawing animals and people into itself during warmer times, then expelling them in colder ones, only to start anew centuries later.’ No one seems to have lived in extreme northeastern Asia.

100,000 years ago, as the sea level fell by 90 metres, a land bridge – Central Beringia – had formed between Asia and America. Genetic, linguistic and archaeological evidence indicates that the first Americans came from northeast Asia as part of the natural dynamics of the hunter-gatherer life around 13,500 BC, following a warming phase that had begun 1,500 years earlier. An ice-free corridor developed in what is now Canada east of the Rockies, and by 12,000 BC humans had reached Chile. By 11,200 BC the ‘Clovis people’ had spread throughout North America.

Much had been said recently about the ‘shutting down the circulation of the Gulf Stream’ – so the mechanism may be explained here. It has been noted that ice grew slowly, but dissipated quickly. Why? Repeatedly, in the Bay of Hudson, as it reached a critical height, the ice slid off the granite base into the Labrador Sea, where it melted. As the sand trapped in the melting ice sank to the bottom, it left the telltale signature of a ‘Heinrich Event’ (after its discoverer). There were eight of them, the last about 13,500 BC. The melting freshwater thinned out the downwelling salt water in the Gulf Stream and stopped the circulation. With the Gulf Stream out of sorts cold, dry and windy conditions settled over North America and Europe.

The latest cold snap (Younger Drias) took place 11,000 BC and lasted about 1,000 years, halting the warming trend that had characterised the period since 13,000 BC. In all likelihood this cold climatic phase was triggered, however, by the catastrophic emptying of the Lake Agassiz, a lake formed by surrounding Laurentide glaciers in Northern Canada and dwarfing the current Great Lakes system.

In Europe, the period between 13,000 and 8,000 BC was ecologically unstable – on the whole, however, forests spread as temperatures rose, driving out big game, or leading it to extinction. Cro-Magnons adapted by becoming omnivorous and living in scattered settlements in clearings near the coasts of lakes and the sea. Technologically they moved on from spears and spear-throwers to the bow.

Warmer conditions in 13,000 BC had brought rain and acorn-rich forests to the Middle East, as well as abundant water. The hunter-gatherers Kebarans extended their range from the Levant all the way into Anatolia. Their descendants, the Natufians, ate plant foods – wild grasses in spring, acorn and pistachio nuts in the fall – and built permanent communities near the trees. From mainstay in the diet hunting became a supplement. Settlement became necessary, for the acorn meal took a long time to prepare. Settlements grew and filled up the landscape. This evolution came to an end 11,000 BC with the arrival of the Younger Drias. In the region even minor shifts in rainfall patterns could trigger major vegetation changes. Forests retreated, and the people attempted to grow grasses to expand the wild harvest. The first domesticated seeds – rye, einkorn, and lentils appeared. This was not enough – and the lands were abandoned. When the warming resumed and the weather turned humid again, agriculture was the staple of life. By 9,500 BC he people were almost completely dependent on cereal agriculture. 500 years later they switched from harvesting gazelles to herding sheep and goats.

Cataclysm was to strike again, around 6,200 BC. Another lake burst in northern Canada, sending a massive outflow of meltwater to the Gulf of Mexico. A 400-year mini-ice-age ensued. To add to the problems, sea levels rose rapidly. After the cold spell, warming resumed, and sea levels rose further. About 5,600 BC the water of the Mediterranean spilled over the Dardanelle Straight into what at the time was a lake – and created the Black Sea.

By 5,000 BC the major climatic shifts were largely over – the long summer had established itself. The period to the present was not a period of stability, however. Even smaller climatic changes yielded momentous impacts for settlements and civilisations. Examples abound. Starting with 5,800 BC cities arose in Mesopotamia, as farmers created ever more complex irrigation systems. A city allowed more centralised social organisation and division of labour for complex irrigation tasks. Surpluses were accumulated to offset droughts. Administrative and religious casts emerged. But the climate remained fickle: About 3,800 BC a period of cold droughts set in. Outlaying farms were abandoned and a landless class became available to work for wages. By 3,200 BC the Sumerian civilisation had emerged. Trade flourished. Akkadians replaced the Sumerians, only to collapse – probably as the result of anomalous droughts.

FAGAN tells this and other stories well, and in the second part of the book he devotes chapters to the fate of many of the civilisations we know, from Egypt to the Mayas. The tale is always the same. Climatic change happens – either of a large scale, as when natural catastrophes occur, or because of natural variability. For a while mankind adapts successfully. Technology allows people to overcome smaller, more common stresses – like the occasional drought that is bridged by stocking food from year to year. In order to do that people unwittingly accept greater vulnerability – by creating permanent settlements they forego the option to migrate in response to long-term climatic shifts. They are prisoners of the system they have created and perish with it. Human history of its interaction with the climate is a cautionary tale.

Yes – climatic change happens, and it really matters little whether it is man-driven or natural in origin. Yes – natural catastrophes dwarfing the tsunami we’ve just experienced happen. Volcanoes have repeatedly triggered droughts or floods and famines. Technology can offset disaster, but can also exacerbate them. And finally, yes – we are not very good at foresight.

Notes

[1] Global warming, e.g., may be far older than we think. As mankind started to cut down forests and developed irrigation the CO2 balance was upset. We should have been in an ice age by now, if things had gone in accordance to the earth’s position with respect to the sun. See William F. Euddiman (2005), ‘How did humans first alter global climate?’ Scientific American CCLXCII, 3 pgs 34-41.

[2] Jaren Diamond (2005), Collapse – How societies choose to fail or succeed. Viking, New York; xi + 575 pgs.

 

Review by Aldo Matteucci

You may also be interested in

41rQ1BuShNL._SY291_BO1204203200_QL40_FMwebp_.webp

Global Warming and Global Politics

Global warming is a pressing issue with far-reaching consequences. It is crucial that global politics address this problem collaboratively, as it affects all nations and requires collective action. The impact of climate change is evident worldwide, and political leaders must prioritize sustainability and environmental protection in their policies. Cooperation on a global scale is necessary to combat the effects of global warming and ensure a sustainable future for all. Political decisions and policies have a significant impact on the environment, and it is essential for leaders to prioritize t...

un-framework.jpg

United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change

The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change aims to address global warming by promoting international cooperation and agreements to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and mitigate climate change impacts.

ucla.png

Small island states in the face of climatic change: The end of the line in international environmental responsibility

Small island states are disproportionately affected by climate change but are least responsible for causing it. They face severe consequences such as rising sea levels and extreme weather events, despite contributing very little to global carbon emissions. This poses a challenge to international environmental responsibility as these countries are vulnerable to the effects of climate change while having limited resources to adapt and mitigate its impacts.

cc.jpg

Climate for Change: Non-state Actors and the Global Politics of the Greenhouse

The text explores the role of non-state actors in global climate politics, analyzing their impact on greenhouse gas emissions and environmental policies. These actors include businesses, NGOs, and local governments, who often operate independently of national governments to address climate change. Their efforts are crucial in mitigating the effects of global warming and pushing for stronger environmental regulations on a global scale.

fagan.jpg

The Long Summer: How Climate Changed Civilisation

Nothing is more changeable than ancient history. As we begin to interpret nature’s archives new insights emerge, overthrowing older orthodoxies, only to be toppled in turn by the next spate of facts. Brian Fagan's latest book too is but history in progress, with a fairly short shelf-life. In some parts it has already been challenged [1].

518GoSqbsmL._SX331_BO1204203200_.jpg

The Roads from Rio: Lessons Learned from Twenty Years of Multilateral Environmental Negotiations

The text discusses key lessons learned from two decades of multilateral environmental negotiations, emphasizing insights gained since the Rio conference.

The Environmental Movement in the Global South

The message explores the environmental movement in the Global South, focusing on the challenges faced and the strategies employed to address environmental issues in developing countries.

1559241540702.jpg

Message on Switzerland’s International Cooperation in 2013-2016

The text discusses Switzerland's international cooperation activities from 2013 to 2016.

A Framework of Best Practices for Caribbean Small States to Meet the Challenges of Climate Change

Caribbean Small States are considered vulnerable by virtue of their geographical peculiarities, economic exigencies, delicate ecosystems and rate of social development among other characteristics. Their ability to meet challenges such as climate change is therefore deficient.

Equity and state representations in climate negotiations

The text examines the dynamics of equity and state representations within climate negotiations, highlighting the complexities and challenges of addressing fairness and inclusivity in global climate governance.

The Global Climate Change Regime

The global climate change regime is a complex system of international agreements and protocols aimed at addressing the challenges posed by climate change. It involves collaboration between countries to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, adapt to the impacts of climate change, and promote sustainable development. The regime is characterized by ongoing negotiations, commitments, and actions to combat climate change on a global scale.

Climate-Change-and-Human-Rights.png

Climate Change and Human Rights: A Rough Guide

This text provides an overview of the intersection between climate change and human rights, emphasizing the impacts on vulnerable populations and the need to address these issues to protect human rights.

41WjafjGtrS._SX329_BO1204203200_.jpg

Ozone Diplomacy: New Directions in Safeguarding the Planet

The message focuses on the book "Ozone Diplomacy: New Directions in Safeguarding the Planet.

Futures-for-dipomacy.png

Futures for diplomacy: Integrative Diplomacy in the 21st Century

The text discusses Integrative Diplomacy in the 21st century, emphasizing the importance of adapting traditional diplomacy to current global challenges and opportunities. Diplomacy is viewed as a tool for addressing complex issues through collaboration and integration, fostering mutual understanding and sustainable solutions. The changing dynamics of international relations require a more inclusive and interconnected approach, focusing on partnerships and cooperation in order to navigate the complexities of the contemporary world. Diplomacy is seen as essential in shaping the future of global ...

Negotiating-and-Implementing-MEAs.png

Negotiating and Implementing MEAs: A Manual for NGOs

The manual provides guidance for non-governmental organizations on negotiating and implementing Multilateral Environmental Agreements (MEAs). It offers practical advice and strategies for NGOs to effectively participate in these processes, ensuring their voice is heard and their expertise is utilized in shaping environmental policies at the international level.

41rh6OJ1p1L._SX325_BO1204203200_.jpg

Climate Change and Small Island States: Power, Knowledge and the South Pacific

The text discusses the challenges small island states in the South Pacific face due to climate change. These states lack power and resources to adequately address climate issues, relying on external knowledge and support. The impact of climate change threatens their very existence, highlighting the urgent need for global cooperation and assistance to combat this crisis.

51SDBSMQLQL._SX329_BO1204203200_.jpg

The Organization of Global Negotiations: Constructing the Climate Change Regime

The text discusses the importance of organizing global negotiations to construct the Climate Change Regime effectively.

Intergovernmental-Panel-on-Climate-Change.png

Fifth Assessment Report: Summary for Policymakers

The document provides a comprehensive summary of the scientific understanding of climate change, highlighting key findings, observed changes, and projected impacts, as assessed by the Working Group I contribution to the Fifth Assessment Report (AR5) of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).

978-3-662-03925-0.jpg

The Kyoto Protocol: International Climate Policy for the 21st Century

The Kyoto Protocol is considered a fundamental agreement in international climate policy for the 21st century, aiming to reduce greenhouse gas emissions to combat global warming.

cc1.png

Climate change, small island developing states

The message highlights the vulnerability of small island developing states to the impacts of climate change. These countries face challenges such as rising sea levels, extreme weather events, and loss of biodiversity. Urgent action is needed to address these issues and support these vulnerable nations in adapting to and mitigating the effects of climate change.

Global environmental diplomacy: Comparing and sharing

The article discusses the importance of global environmental diplomacy in addressing environmental issues and highlights the benefits of comparing and sharing strategies among nations.

5128xhqKZ5L._SY291_BO1204203200_QL40_FMwebp_.webp

Global Environmental Politics

Global Environmental Politics discusses the intricate relationships between politics, society, and the environment. It delves into how political decisions impact environmental issues and how societal actions can influence political agendas regarding global environmental challenges. By examining the interplay between various stakeholders, policies, and power dynamics, the book sheds light on the complexities of environmental governance on a global scale.

31YMwJKaCeS._SY291_BO1204203200_QL40_FMwebp_.webp

A New Diplomacy for Sustainable Development: The Challenge of Global Change

The text discusses the need for a new diplomacy approach to address the challenges of global change and foster sustainable development.

41S0WkllIwL._SY291_BO1204203200_QL40_FMwebp_.webp

The International Climate Change regime: A Guide to Rules, Institutions and Procedures

The International Climate Change regime is a comprehensive guide that outlines the rules, institutions, and procedures related to addressing climate change on a global scale.

csd_logo.gif

Management of Natural and Environmental Disasters in Small Island Developing States

The message emphasizes the importance of disaster management in small island developing states due to their vulnerability to natural calamities. These states face unique challenges like limited resources, geographic isolation, and climate change impact. Capacity building, international cooperation, and innovative solutions are suggested as key strategies to enhance disaster resilience in these vulnerable regions.

download-3.jpg

Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change

The Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change outlines international commitments to reducing greenhouse gas emissions to combat climate change.

On-Behalf-of-My-Delegation.png

On Behalf of My Delegation,…: A Survival Guide for Developing Country Climate Negotiators

The one hundred pages of this book are in fact a useful Survival Guide for those approaching climate change negotiations for the first time. It has been written for developing country delegates, but delegates from other countries can also profit from its reading the same way that a similar survival guide for industrialized country delegates would be useful for those coming from developing countries, because it is necessary to know both sides of the story

download-1-2.png

Summary of the Doha Climate Change Conference

Summary of the Doha Climate Change Conference. The Doha Climate Change Conference held in 2012 aimed to advance global efforts to address climate change. The conference resulted in an extension of the Kyoto Protocol, commitments for a new global agreement by 2015, and pledges by developed countries to provide financial support to developing nations. Additionally, the conference emphasized the importance of adaptation measures for vulnerable countries and discussed the need for long-term climate finance mechanisms. The conference highlighted the need for cooperation and collective action to com...

51HP9X4Y3DL._SY291_BO1204203200_QL40_FMwebp_.webp

The Greening of Machiavelli: The Evolution of International Environmental Policy

The Greening of Machiavelli: The Evolution of International Environmental Policy" discusses the transformation of environmental policy on a global scale, reflecting a shift towards sustainability and cooperation.

fao.png

Environment and Natural Resources in Small Island Developing States

The message is likely a discussion or information about the environment and natural resources in Small Island Developing States.

UNEP.png

Manual on Compliance with and Enforcement of Multilateral Environmental Agreements

The text provides comprehensive guidance on compliance with and enforcement of multilateral environmental agreements, offering practical strategies and tools for enhancing global environmental governance.

undp.png

Reducing Disaster Risk: A Challenge for Development

The text discusses the complex challenge of reducing disaster risk in development projects.

download-2.gif

Roaring Mice Against the Tide: The South Pacific Islands and Agenda-Building on Global Warming

The text discusses how South Pacific Islands are exerting influence in global warming agenda-building despite their small size.

41cGinK0tFS._SY291_BO1204203200_QL40_FMwebp_.webp

International Relations and Global Climate Change

International relations play a crucial role in addressing global climate change. Cooperation among nations is essential to develop and implement effective solutions to combat climate change. Additionally, international agreements like the Paris Agreement serve as frameworks for countries to work together towards reducing greenhouse gas emissions and mitigating the impacts of climate change on a global scale. By fostering collaboration and sharing resources, countries can make significant progress in the fight against climate change.

download-1.jpg

A Future for Small States: Overcoming Vulnerability

The message provides strategies for small states to overcome vulnerability and thrive in the future.

41McUr3xIML._SX331_BO1204203200_.jpg

Saving the Mediterranean: The Politics of International Environmental Cooperation

The text discusses the complexities of international environmental cooperation in the Mediterranean region, focusing on the political aspects involved in efforts to save the environment.

41dqc1fx41L._SX331_BO1204203200_.jpg

Environmental Diplomacy: Negotiating More Effective Global Agreements

The text is likely an article discussing the importance of environmental diplomacy in negotiating effective global agreements.