Aldo Matteucci   01 Aug 2020   Diplo Blog, Diplomacy

Printer Friendly and PDF

Diplo Wisdom Circle

Today’s Guardian brings an interesting diplomatic issue into in the news: you can read it here. It raises a wealth of questions in international law but it also in national culture.

As an international diplomat, you may want to address issues in international law like:

  • Is a successor regime liable for the extra-territorial misdeeds of the previous one?
  • What does 'sponsorship mean and who determines it?
  • Is a state liable for the misdeeds of terrorist groups by virtue of their presence in its territory?
  • If the victims are dead, who is entitled to monetary compensation?
  • How far does the entitlement go back in time or forward into the future? If so, who sets the cut-off dates?
  • How do determine the level of compensation, also in relation to national entitlements?
  • What of any antecedent military retaliation?
  • Does monetary compensation bring closure to the issue?
  • Who supervises the distribution of monetary compensation, particularly if the victims are from different countries?

These questions have been at the core of grievous conflicts in the twentieth century. Check for analogies and precedents. The list of questions is far from complete, so try to imagine yourself tasked with a just, rather than an expedient solution.

Beware: we deal here with principle issues, not an actual context. In other terms we would argue in 'if statements' like the EUSCJ does.

Discussion topic

Cultures react differently to such issues. How does your nation deal with:

  • embracing defeat;
  • accepting closure;
  • burden of compensation for the state;
  • adequacy of compensation; and
  • internal issues of monetary compensation?

Bearing in mind the difference between 'extremism' and 'acceptable' ideology.

Join the discussion in the comments below!

Leave a Reply

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
  • You may use [view:name=display=args] tags to display views.
CAPTCHA This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.