|
A
very busy man, dividing his time between his political
and literary pursuits, Benjamin Disraeli had a standard
reply, unmatched for diplomatic ambiguity, for wouldbe
authors who sent him manuscripts to read. “Many thanks”,
he would write back, “I shall lose no time in reading
it.” |
|
D
E F I N I T I O N S
A
word, phrase, or sentence is ambiguous if it has more than one
meaning. (Kent Bach, Routledge
Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on Ambiguity)
…any
verbal nuance, however slight, which gives room for alternative
reactions to the same piece of language. (William Empson, Seven
Types of Ambiguity, London: Hogarth Press, 1927, quoted by
Norman Scott, "Ambiguity
versus Precision: The Changing Role of Terminology in Conference
Diplomacy," Language and Diplomacy, Malta: DiploProjects, 2001)
…ambiguities
are pieces of language that 1. can be interpreted as meaning A, 2.
can be interpreted as meaning B, and 3. cannot be interpreted as A
and B simultaneously, but, eventually, as a neutral (re)source, from
which, under specific focuses of vision/interpretation, both A and B
might at separate times spring…In order to qualify as an ambiguity
an expression must generate not only “at least two different
meanings”, but also two incompatible and unrelated meanings.
It is only then that an expression is truly ambiguous (Drazen Pehar,
"Use
of Ambiguities in Peace Agreements," Language and
Diplomacy, Malta: DiploProjects, 2001)
…ambiguity
is a one-many relation between syntax and sense. (Geoffrey Leech, Semantics,
Harmondsworth: Penguin Books, 1987, quoted by Pehar)

A
good visual model of ambiguity is the well-known “duck-rabbit”
picture, a drawing which can be seen as either a duck or a rabbit,
but not both at the same time. This picture thus includes two
separate and incompatible possibilities.
For
more information on how people resolve ambiguity in language read Ambiguous
Words by Dr George Miller. |